Drawings say one thing and the specification another: who wins under NEC?

What to do when NEC contract documents conflict, how the Project Manager's ruling is priced, and why the reading that favours you can matter.

Communications and recordsScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. How the price is worked out
  4. What to record
  5. What not to do
  6. When to get help
  7. Example
  8. Related guides

The drawing shows one thing, the specification demands another, and the work is about to start. Neither document wins automatically, so what matters is who wrote the Scope and what you do next.

The short answer

Nothing in the core clauses ranks one document above another, so tell the Project Manager (the person the Client appoints to run the contract day to day) straight away under clause 17.1 and ask them to say how it should be resolved. If their answer changes the Scope, it is a compensation event, which is the contract's term for something that can change your price or dates. The price is then worked out against the reading that suits whoever did not write the Scope. Look for a precedence clause in any Z clauses (extra conditions the Client adds), because those can change this.

What to do, step by step

  1. Notify as soon as you spot it. Clause 17.1 puts the duty on both you and the Project Manager. No period is stated, so do it immediately.
  2. Do not guess which version to build. Say which work is affected and the date you need a decision by. If the delay would hurt, add an early warning (15.1).
  3. Ask for the Project Manager's ruling and diary the period for reply. A late answer is itself an event under 60.1(6).
  4. Check what the ruling does. If it changes the Scope, it is an event under 60.1(1), so notify it with the instruction.
  5. Quote on the favourable reading, showing both versions.

How the price is worked out

Under clause 63.10 (63.8 in NEC3 ECC) the assessment assumes your Prices and dates were built on the reading that suits the party who did not write the Scope. The author of the muddle pays for it.

  • Client wrote the Scope: the favourable reading is the one best for you. If the Client picks the dearer version, the Prices rise. If it picks the cheaper one, you are measured against that, so usually nothing changes.
  • You wrote it, in your own design: the favourable reading is best for the Client. You cannot charge for the better version, and altering your own design to suit other Scope is not an event under 60.1(1).

What to record

  • Both document references and the exact conflicting text.
  • The date you noticed and the date you notified.
  • The date the answer is needed to hold the Accepted Programme.
  • What you priced, so you can show the favourable reading.

What not to do

  • Do not assume the specification always beats the drawings. The core clauses have no such rule.
  • Do not treat Site Information as Scope. A conflict there about ground conditions falls under 60.3.
  • Do not confuse a gap with a conflict. Where the Scope is silent, ask whether the item is incidental to the described work; it may already be in your price.
  • Do not ignore bill errors. Under Options B and D, clauses 60.6 and 60.7 deal with them.
  • Do not wait until the week of the pour.

When to get help

Involve a commercial manager if the reply is that you should have queried it at tender, or that the specification always prevails. Ask where that rule is written: tender documents or amendments might hold it, the core clauses do not. Often the real argument is whether the documents truly conflict. Something impossible or unlawful is dealt with under 17.2, and the Project Manager changes the Scope.

Example

A warehouse slab on an Option A contract. The Client's drawing shows 150mm and its specification says 175mm. You priced 150mm. The Project Manager rules that 175mm applies. The change is assessed from 150mm. Extra concrete and a longer pour cost £30,000, plus a 10% Fee of £3,000, so the Prices rise by £33,000. If they had ruled for 150mm, nothing changes. Even if you had priced 175mm, the assessment still starts from the favourable 150mm.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?