Who pays when a defect appears after Completion but before the defects date?

Work out whether it is a Defect, who must fix it, the notification and correction clock, and how each main Option treats the cost.

Defects, quality and completionScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. Is it a Defect at all?
  4. Cost by main Option
  5. What to record
  6. What not to do
  7. When to get help
  8. Example
  9. Related guides

The works are complete and something has started to go wrong. You want to know whether you have to fix it and at whose cost.

The short answer

If it is a Defect (work that does not meet the Scope, the document setting out what you must deliver) and comes to light before the defects date, you correct it and the cost generally stays with you, with the correction period running from the day of notification. Clause numbers here are NEC4 ECC (notifying 43.2, correcting 44.2); NEC3 uses 42.2 and 43.2. The question that settles it: did the item fail the Scope, or has it merely worn out, been damaged by someone else, or followed a design the Client supplied?

What to do, step by step

  1. Ensure it is notified. The Supervisor (who checks quality for the Client) and you each notify Defects as soon as you become aware, up to the defects date.
  2. Calculate the deadline. Contract Data sets the period, counted from notification, and it can differ between types of Defect.
  3. Secure access. For a part already taken over, the Project Manager must get the Client to let you in, and your clock stays paused until it does (44.4). Write down the date you got in.
  4. Settle the cause if it is disputed. Until the defects date the Supervisor may order a search (43.1). If it finds nothing, you have a compensation event under 60.1(10).
  5. Correct, then ask the Supervisor to confirm, and repeat any test that first showed the problem.

Is it a Defect at all?

What happened Defect? Who pays
Pipes laid to the wrong fall Yes You
Your design breaks the law or departs from your accepted design Yes You
Built to the Scope, but the Client's own design was wrong No Client (80.1)
Client's staff damaged it after take over No Client
Normal wear or poor maintenance No, if it met the Scope Client
Damage caused by a concealed fault already there at take over Exception in 80.1 puts it back on you You

If the Scope sets a performance or design-life requirement, a failure in use can be a Defect even when the installed product looks fine.

Cost by main Option

Option Correction cost after Completion
A and B Prices do not change, so you absorb it
C and D Disallowed Cost
E Disallowed Cost
Any, with X15 Design Defects may fall elsewhere where your designer showed proper skill and care

You can look to your Subcontractor or designer, but that does not delay your duty to the Client.

What to record

  • Who found it, when, and how it was notified.
  • Photographs, test results and the Scope clause relied on.
  • The date access was given.
  • The correction date and the date it was closed.

What not to do

  • Do not argue "it is maintenance" without evidence such as service records and the O&M manual.
  • Do not assume that being the original builder makes every failure yours.
  • Do not leave verbal promises. State the correction date in writing.

When to get help

Involve a commercial manager if the same fault keeps coming back, because that can signal a deeper design or system issue. Seek legal advice for consequential losses such as business interruption, which the Defects clauses do not deal with.

Example

A fictional office fit-out reaches Completion on 1 April with a four-week correction period. In September a leaking pipe joint is notified on 14 September, so the correction date would be 12 October. The tenant only allows access from 21 September, so the period starts then and ends 19 October.

Figure 1. The office fit-out example. A leaking joint is notified on 14 September with a four-week defect correction period, which would have ended on 12 October; the tenant only gives access on 21 September, so the clock is paused for seven days, the period starts then and the correction date becomes 19 October.
Figure 1. The office fit-out example. A leaking joint is notified on 14 September with a four-week defect correction period, which would have ended on 12 October; the tenant only gives access on 21 September, so the clock is paused for seven days, the period starts then and the correction date becomes 19 October. Open full size

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?